Skip to Content
Platform.Ontology

Photo library, add only

Saves a photo or video into the library without being able to read any of it.

Asks you firstFiles and storagePhotos and mediaAndroid and iPhoneWhile you use it

In one line

Can save new photos and videos to your library, but cannot look at what is there

Saves a photo or video into the library without being able to read any of it.

Lets an app drop images in (camera, scanner, meme maker) with no view of what is already stored, a far smaller disclosure than reading the roll.

What it can and can't do

What the user does: You tap Save photo, Save to gallery or Download image

It can

  • Save a new photo or video into your library
  • Save the app's own media on Android with no prompt
  • Ask for add only permission on iPhone, shown as Allow or Don't Allow
  • Keep saved items in your gallery

It cannot

  • See any existing photo or video in your library
  • List albums or count your photos
  • Delete or change the photos already there
  • Save on iPhone without your tap on the add only prompt

How it differs between platforms: Android needs no permission for the app's own new media. iPhone shows an add only prompt.

On Android and iPhone

AndroidiPhone
StatusSupportedSupported
First versionAndroid 10 (API 29)iOS 11
Permission or entitlementNot listedNSPhotoLibraryAddUsageDescription
Protection levelnoneprompt
How access is grantednoneprompt
What the user seesNone: MediaStore insert into the app's own pending item shows no promptAllow, Don't Allow (add-only wording)
How long it lastsItem remains; app may modify only files it createdUntil revoked
How to take it backn/a (the app can only touch its own items)Settings > Privacy & Security > Photos > Add Photos Only
Store policyNone listedApp Review 5.1.1: ask for the smallest access
APIMediaStore.Images.Media.EXTERNAL_CONTENT_URI insert, IS_PENDING flagPHPhotoLibrary.requestAuthorization(for: .addOnly), UIImageWriteToSavedPhotosAlbum
NotesScoped storage (API 29) means writing your own media needs no permissionAdd-only still allows saving with the older UIImageWriteToSavedPhotosAlbum path

Data you get

What comes back: Write confirmation
Shape: event
How often: per save

FieldTypeUnitRangePrecision
savedAssetIdstringidlocal identifierNot listed

Technical limits

  • Read back of the saved item is not guaranteed on iOS add-only
  • Cannot enumerate other apps' media on either platform

The story

What it is

Lets an app save a photo or video to your library without seeing what is already there.

For you

A pop up asks to add photos only. If you say yes, a camera app can save a picture but cannot look at your other photos. It is a much smaller share than full access.

For makers

Makers need it to save results like scans, edits and downloads. Asking for add only keeps trust high and is easier to get approved.

Where you see it

TypeExampleApps
creativeA camera app saves new pictures to your library and cannot see old ones.None named
productivityA document scanner saves a scan as a photo in your library.None named
socialA meme or sticker maker saves a finished image to share.None named
gamesA game saves a screenshot of your best score.None named
shoppingA retailer saves a QR code or coupon image to your photos.None named
ar-vrAn AR app saves a photo of a 3D object in your room.None named
mediaA video downloader saves a clip you chose.None named

Risks

  • Smaller risk
  • Still adds clutter to your library

Android and iPhone in short

  • Android: Android apps can save through MediaStore with no permission on recent versions.
  • iPhone: A separate add only choice in the Photos permission.

What the platform says

Good uses and abuse

Legitimate uses

  • Saving a scan
  • Exporting an edit

Known abuse

  • None notable

Scores

ScoreValueMeaning
Sensitivity1 of 5How revealing the data is
Utility4 of 5How useful it is to honest apps
Friction1 of 5How much the user has to do
Fingerprint bitsNot ratedRough identifying entropy, when known

History

  • 2019-09, Android 10 (API 29): Scoped storage: no permission to write own media
  • 2020-09, iPhone iOS 14: .addOnly access level API added
  • Photo library, full access. Can see and change every photo and video in your library once you allow full access
  • Photo picker. Can open only the photos you pick from a system gallery, with no permission asked

Sources

How well checked: Based on official documentation.

On this page