Skip to Content
Platform.Ontology

Visit monitoring

iOS reports the places a person stays at (arrival and departure) without constant GPS.

Works without askingNotifications and backgroundLocation in backgroundAndroid and iPhoneIn the background

In one line

Can learn which places you stay at, with arrival and leave times, on iPhone

iOS reports the places a person stays at (arrival and departure) without constant GPS.

Infers home, work and frequent stops with low power. The app gets coarse arrival and departure times and places, a daily routine map.

What it can and can't do

What the user does: You allow Always location for a feature that keeps a place history or journal

It can

  • Learn about stops, like home, work or a cafe, without constant tracking
  • Get arrival and departure times plus a rough spot on the map
  • Wake up in the background when a visit is noticed

It cannot

  • Report a visit right away; delays can run from minutes to hours
  • Work at all without Always location
  • Know what you did there, only where and when
  • Match this on Android, which has no visit service for apps; it must guess with geofences

How it differs between platforms: iPhone has a built in visit service. Android has none for outside apps and has to guess from geofences.

On Android and iPhone

AndroidiPhone
StatusPartialSupported
First versionAndroid 10 (API 29)iOS 8.0
Permission or entitlementACCESS_BACKGROUND_LOCATIONNSLocationAlwaysAndWhenInUseUsageDescription
Protection leveldangerousprompt
How access is grantedpromptprompt
What the user seesAllow all the timeAlways authorization
How long it lastsUntil revokedDelivered after the fact, relaunches app
How to take it backSettings > LocationSettings > Privacy > Location
Store policyPlay: background location reviewApp Review 5.1.1
APIActivity Recognition Transition API (ACTIVITY_RECOGNITION) and geofence dwell transitionsCLLocationManager.startMonitoringVisits(), CLVisit
NotesNo place level visit API for third parties; dwell via geofence loitering delayVisits delivered with arrival and departure dates and a coordinate with horizontal accuracy; delay minutes to hours

Data you get

What comes back: Visit
Shape: event
How often: On arrival or departure

FieldTypeUnitRangePrecision
arrivalDatedatetimeNoneNot listed1 s
departureDatedatetimeNoneNot listed1 s
horizontalAccuracyfloatmtens to hundredscoarse

Technical limits

  • Delayed delivery
  • Only on iOS

The story

What it is

iPhone can tell an app when you arrived at and left a place you stay, without constant GPS.

For you

You never see it. An app quietly learns that you spend nights at one place and days at another, which can power helpful suggestions or a very detailed routine map.

For makers

Makers can learn home, work and frequent stops cheaply. It powers place memory and context features, and it is sensitive because routine shows who you are.

Where you see it

TypeExampleApps
mapsA map app builds a timeline of places you visited today.Apple Maps, Google Maps
productivityA journaling app adds the cafe where you wrote an entry.Day One
adsAn ad company infers which stores you visit most for audience groups.None named
fitnessA fitness app notices you are at the gym and offers to start a workout.None named
shoppingA loyalty app counts a visit to the store without any check in.None named
analyticsA research app measures how long people spend at parks.None named

Risks

  • Reveals home, work and routine
  • Sensitive places can be inferred

Android and iPhone in short

  • Android: No exact match for third party apps. Apps use geofences with a dwell delay.
  • iPhone: Visits come with arrival and departure times and a spot, but delivery can lag by minutes to hours.

What the platform says

  • Apple: Visit monitoring. Apple offers a low power way to be told when a person arrives at or leaves a place where they spend time.

Good uses and abuse

Legitimate uses

  • Place based suggestions

Known abuse

  • Inferring home and work

Scores

ScoreValueMeaning
Sensitivity5 of 5How revealing the data is
Utility3 of 5How useful it is to honest apps
Friction3 of 5How much the user has to do
Fingerprint bitsNot ratedRough identifying entropy, when known

History

  • 2014-09, iPhone iOS 8: CLVisit monitoring introduced

Sources

How well checked: Based on official documentation.

On this page