Sign in with Apple and Credential Manager
Account sign in that can hide the real email behind a relay address.
In one line
Can sign you in with Apple and hide your real email if you choose
Account sign in that can hide the real email behind a relay address.
Apple required it where other social logins existed until January 2024. Android uses Credential Manager.
What it can and can't do
What the user does: You tap Sign in with Apple and choose Share or Hide My Email
It can
- Create an account using your Apple ID with Face ID or Touch ID
- Get a steady user ID for your account
- Receive a private relay email instead of your real one
- Learn your name on the first sign in only
It cannot
- See your Apple ID password
- See your real email when you pick Hide My Email
- Get your name again on later sign ins
- Use your sign in on another developer's app
How it differs between platforms: Apple offers a Hide My Email relay. On Android, Credential Manager offers Google, passkeys and passwords with a more limited scope.
On Android and iPhone
| Android | iPhone | |
|---|---|---|
| Status | Supported | Supported |
| First version | Android 14 (API 34) | iOS 13 |
| Permission or entitlement | None; Credential Manager with Google ID, passkeys, passwords | com.apple.developer.applesignin |
| Protection level | none | entitlement |
| How access is granted | prompt | prompt |
| What the user sees | Credential Manager bottom sheet | Sign in with Apple sheet with Hide My Email |
| How long it lasts | Until sign out | Until revoked |
| How to take it back | Google account settings | Settings > Apple Account > Sign in with Apple |
| Store policy | Play: account deletion policy | App Review 4.8 login services |
| API | CredentialManager | ASAuthorizationAppleIDProvider |
| Notes | Hide My Email equivalent is Google's limited scope | Returns stable user id; email may be a relay address; name only on first sign in |
Data you get
What comes back: Credential
Shape: object
How often: per sign in
| Field | Type | Unit | Range | Precision |
|---|---|---|---|---|
userId | string | opaque | stable per team | Not listed |
email | string | address | real or relay | Not listed |
Technical limits
- Name and email are delivered once
- Relay email forwards only if the developer registers sending domains
The story
What it is
You sign in with your Apple account and can hide your real email address.
For you
You see a black Apple button, tap it and confirm with Face ID. You can pick Hide My Email, so the app gets a random address that forwards to your real inbox. You can switch it off later.
For makers
Makers get a fast sign up with a verified account, which means more finished sign ups. If you hide your email, they cannot easily link you to other data. It also means the maker must send mail to the relay and cannot simply sell your address.
Where you see it
| Type | Example | Apps |
|---|---|---|
| shopping | A store account starts with one tap and a forwarding email, so promo mail never hits your main inbox. | None named |
| social | A social app creates your profile from your Apple name without asking you to type it. | None named |
| games | A game ties your save file to your Apple account so it restores on a new iPhone. | None named |
| media | A news app uses a relay email so it can send newsletters, and you can turn them off at the source. | None named |
| dating | A dating app signs you up faster and sees only the name you choose to share. | None named |
| ads | A marketer finds relay emails harder to match across companies, which weakens cross app tracking. | None named |
Risks
- Account linking by the maker
- Lock in to an Apple account
Android and iPhone in short
- Android: Android apps show a Credential Manager sheet and may offer Sign in with Apple through the web.
- iPhone: iPhone apps get the native Apple button, with a required relay email option when it is used.
What the platform says
- Apple: Sign in with Apple. A private, simple way to sign in with Face ID, with the option to hide your email address.
- Google: Credential Manager. Android's single sign in sheet for passwords, passkeys and federated sign in options.
Good uses and abuse
Legitimate uses
- Fewer passwords
Known abuse
- Linking accounts across apps
Scores
| Score | Value | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Sensitivity | 3 of 5 | How revealing the data is |
| Utility | 4 of 5 | How useful it is to honest apps |
| Friction | 2 of 5 | How much the user has to do |
| Fingerprint bits | 20 | Rough identifying entropy, when known |
History
- 2019-09, iPhone iOS 13: Sign in with Apple introduced
- 2019-09, iPhone iOS 13: Sign in with Apple introduced; required by 4.8 if other social login is offered
- 2022-06, iPhone iOS 16: Account deletion rule 5.1.1(v) requires token revocation
- 2024-01, iPhone App Review: Guideline 4.8 revised to allow any privacy preserving login
- 2024-01, iPhone App Review 4.8 update: Any equivalent privacy-focused login service may satisfy 4.8
Related capabilities
Related
- App Attest and Play Integrity. Can prove its requests come from the real app on a genuine phone
- Sign in with Google. Can sign you in with a Google account already on your phone after you tap
- Passkeys in an app (create and sign in). Can create and use passkeys inside the app after you approve with your device lock
Same idea on the web
- Sign in with Apple. Can sign you in with Apple and get a real or hidden email address
- WebAuthn passkey registration. Can create a passkey or security key login for one site
- Apple Hide My Email relay. Can only see a random Apple address that forwards mail to your real inbox
- FedCM (Federated Credential Management). Can sign you in with Google, Apple or similar using a browser account picker
Sources
- Apple: Sign in with Apple
- Android: Credential Manager
- App Review Guideline 4.8
- Apple: Sign in with Apple
How well checked: Based on official documentation.