Bookmarks and reading list
Sites cannot read your bookmarks or reading list.
In one line
Can't see your bookmarks or reading list
Sites cannot read your bookmarks or reading list.
Only browser extensions with the bookmarks permission can read them. A web page has no API at all; even installing a PWA is detectable only through display-mode.
What it can and can't do
What the user does: Nothing. Pages have no way to ask for this
It can
- Tell if the page runs as an installed app
- Show a prompt to add to your home screen
- Ask you to bookmark it, but only you can do that
It cannot
- See any saved bookmark
- See your reading list
- Know if you bookmarked the site
- Change your bookmarks; only an extension with permission can
Browser support
| Browser | Status | First version | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chrome | Not supported | Not available | None |
| Edge | Not supported | Not available | None |
| Firefox | Not supported | Not available | None |
| Safari | Not supported | Not available | None |
| Safari on iPhone | Not supported | Not available | None |
| Chrome on Android | Not supported | Not available | None |
| Samsung Internet | Not supported | Not available | None |
How a site asks for it
| API | none |
| How access is granted | not-exposed |
| What the user sees | None |
| Needs a secure context (HTTPS) | No |
| Needs a user gesture | No |
| How long it lasts | read fresh on every page load; nothing stored |
| How to take it back | not applicable |
| Inside an iframe | Readable from cross-origin iframes too (same values) |
Typical flow
- Page script reads the value
- No prompt is shown
Data you get
Shape: none
How often: static per session
| Field | Type | Unit | Range | Precision |
|---|---|---|---|---|
proxy: display-mode standalone | string | None | page knows if it was launched as an installed app | Not listed |
proxy: beforeinstallprompt event | string | None | shows the page is installable, not bookmarks | Not listed |
Technical limits
- Interests leak
The story
What it is
Sites cannot read your bookmarks or reading list.
For you
Your saved sites stay between you and your browser. A web page has no way to look at them. Only a browser extension you install and allow can.
For makers
Sites would love to know what you save, because it shows your real interests. The web gives no such access. They can only see how you arrive and, with an installed web app, how you launch it.
Where you see it
| Type | Example | Apps |
|---|---|---|
| shopping | A shop wanted to know whether you bookmarked it, to see loyalty. It must use sign-in and repeat visits instead. | None named |
| news | A publisher wanted your saved articles, and instead offers its own Save for later button. | Medium |
| productivity | A read it later site wants your reading list, so it asks you to import a file or use an extension. | None named |
| ads | An advertiser wanted bookmarks for interest data, which are not available to pages. | None named |
| analytics | A product team wants to know who bookmarked the page and settles for return visits. | None named |
| security | A tracker wanted to link your saved sites to a profile, which the browser blocks. | None named |
| games | A game site wanted to remind you to come back, so it asks you to install the web app instead. | None named |
Risks
- Only extensions you install can read them
Good uses and abuse
Legitimate uses
- None: the browser deliberately withholds it
Known abuse
- Sites attempt proxies to recover it
Scores
| Score | Value | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Sensitivity | 4 of 5 | How revealing the data is |
| Utility | 2 of 5 | How useful it is to honest apps |
| Friction | 3 of 5 | How much the user has to do |
| Fingerprint bits | 0 | Rough identifying entropy, when known |
Sources
How well checked: Based on official documentation.